by puchu
We have played now something like 10 times.First one with components A,B,D; second one A,C,D; after that always B,C,D. Most of the times we played in 3 players, with exception of 3 times with a "fake" 4th (controlled by everyone) and one game in 5, with two people at their first game.
We lost ONLY once (4p, B-C-D components) with VERY unlucky rolls and card sequence. We always played with the same strategy (more or less) since the first game, and started thinking that the game is someway "bugged". Yes, there is not a lot of Atlantis unflipped at the end, but it is absurd we almost never lose.
We are thinking of going through the rules again to see if there is some major mistake in the way we play (but it doesn't seems so), otherwise I assume we are not going to play it anymore.
As co-op game, we play ghost stories and pandemic often, we played forbidden island as well.