bewareness wrote:
With all due respect, after reading the major comparisons you draw between COC and SMC, i was a little suprised as you only have one COC game under your belt.
First impressions are IMHO not enough to draw a comparison between these two wonderfull games. I played both and think both have enough variation to be two CIV games that need both a different approach. A black and white break down of general issues doesn't do right to either of these games.
Thanks for the session report/comparison. For me both games get a 9.25 not because they play the same but because of there unique mechanisms that provide the players with enough variation and diversity.
Keep the positive comments coming in...
First impressions are IMHO not enough to draw a comparison between these two wonderfull games. I played both and think both have enough variation to be two CIV games that need both a different approach. A black and white break down of general issues doesn't do right to either of these games.
Thanks for the session report/comparison. For me both games get a 9.25 not because they play the same but because of there unique mechanisms that provide the players with enough variation and diversity.
Keep the positive comments coming in...
However I mentioned quite a few times I just had one game in so far. So everyone should know to take this report with a grain of salt. And with all due respect - one game is definitely enough to make out the huge differences in gameplay that I was trying to point out.
Essentially, you and I draw the same conclusion, as is stated in the bold marked part.