aaarg_ink wrote:
Its the one problem with the BGG rating system, but I'm not sure how you work around it. There are many ways to rate games, in the end the recommendations are based on "desire to play" so that's how I rate them (after having tried personal systems before).
Desire to play is a *part* of the rating system, not the entirety. The quality of the game is supposed to be reflected as well.
A game you've loved for years and the worst game in the world shouldn't both get the same low rating because you've played that favourite 1000 times and don't plan to play any more.